Make Text Larger Make Text Smaller Email this Article to a Friend Print this Article

Fellay silences Williamson, Pope reaffirms solidarity with Jews

Published: January 29, 2009

Pope Benedict on Wednesday reaffirmed his "full and unquestionable solidarity" with Jews while SSPX Archbishop Bernard Fellay has silenced Holocaust minimising Bishop Richard Williamson over his remarks.

Speaking at his Wednesday audience, the German born pope said the attempt to exterminate the Jews in the Holocaust should remain a warning for all people, The International Herald Tribune reports.

The pope said: "While I renew with affection the expression of my full and unquestionable solidarity with our (Jewish) brothers, I hope the memory of the Shoah will induce humanity to reflect on the unpredictable power of hate when it conquers the heart of man."

Shoah is the Hebrew word for the Holocaust.

The pope, who did not mention Williamson by name, said the Holocaust should remain for all a "warning against denial and reductionism."

More criticism from Jewish leaders

Williamson's comments caused a storm of criticism from Jews, who say it set back Catholic-Jewish dialogue by half a century.

Elie Wiesel, the death camp survivor, author and Nobel Peace Prize winner said Pope Benedict has given credence to "the most vulgar aspect of anti-Semitism" by rehabilitating a Holocaust denying bishop.

Wiesel told Reuters that  there was no way the Vatican could have not known about the bishop's past and it may have been done "intentionally."

The Chief Rabbinate of Israel has also indefinitely broken off relations with the Vatican over the lifting of the excommunications, ANSA says.

The move was announced by the Chief Rabbinate director general, Oded Weiner, who also said that a March 2-4 meeting in Rome with the Catholic Church's Commission for Religious Relations with Jews had been cancelled.

News of the rabbinate's decision appeared first on the Jerusalem Post website and the pope quickly responded by reiterating his full support for his "Jewish brothers" and said the Holocaust must not be denied because ''the memory of the Shoah regenerates our humanity and helps us reflect on the unexpected power which evil can exert on the hearts of man''.

Vatican spokesman Father Federico Lombardo expressed his hope that the pope's words would be "more than sufficient for anyone who had any doubts over the views of the Holy Father and the Church" on the Holocaust.

He added that he also hoped that this will be sufficient to avoid any break in relations between the Holy See and the Rabbinate.

The Jerusalem Post also called in an editorial for Israel's ambassador to the Holy See to be recalled for consultations.

SSPX apologises

On Tuesday the head of the society of Pius X, Bishop Bernard Fellay, denied that Williamson's views reflected those of the order and apologised to the pope for any problems his statements may have created.

He apologised to Pope Benedict XVI and those of "good faith" following Williamson's remarks, in a statement released by the Vatican on Tuesday.

"The declarations of Monsignor Williamson do not reflect in any way the position of our society. That is why I forbade him, until new order, from taking any public stances on political or historical questions," he said.

"We ask forgiveness to the Sovereign Pontiff and all the men of good will for the dramatic consequences of such an act," the statement said.

The Vatican released a statement from Bishop Fellay, superior of the Priestly Fraternity of St. Pius X and one of the four traditionalist bishops whose excommunication was rescinded in a Jan. 21 decree from the Congregation for Bishops.

In his statement Bishop Fellay said "It's clear that a Catholic bishop cannot speak with ecclesiastical authority except on questions that regard faith and morals. Our Fraternity does not claim any authority on other matters. Its mission is the propagation and restoration of authentic Catholic doctrine, expressed in the dogmas of the faith. It's for this reason that we are known, accepted and respected in the entire world.

"It's with great sadness that we recognise the extent to which the violation of this mandate has done damage to our mission. The affirmations of Bishop Williamson do not reflect in any sense the position of our Fraternity. For this reason I have prohibited him, pending any new orders, from taking any public positions on political or historical questions.

"We ask the forgiveness of the Supreme Pontiff, and of all people of good will, for the dramatic consequences of this act. Because we recognise how ill-advised these declarations were, we can only look with sadness at the way in which they have directly struck our Fraternity, discrediting its mission.

"This is something we cannot accept, and we declare that we will continue to preach Catholic doctrine and to administer the sacraments of grace of Our Lord Jesus Christ.

More Catholic reaction

The Swiss bishops' conference said the traditionalist bishop's remarks "worsened concerns" over the "deep divergences" between the society and the Catholic Church.

The Swiss bishops condemned Bishop Williamson's comments and apologized to the Jewish community in Switzerland for the upsetting episode.

"Those who know Benedict XVI and his positive attitude toward Judaism know that the indefensible ravings of Bishop Williamson will not be tolerated," they said.

Matthias Kopp, spokesman for the German bishops' conference, told German television that, "sooner or later, Williamson will have to take back his statements," which he called unacceptable.

SOURCES

Pope reaches out to Jews angered by bishop's Holocaust statement (International Herald Tribune)

Breaking News: Holocaust denier bishop gagged (National Catholic Reporter)

Rabbinate cuts ties with Vatican (ANSA)

Vatican highlights pope's Holocaust condemnations (Associated Press)

Holocaust denial by traditionalist bishop is unacceptable, says Vatican (Catholic News Service)

Swiss bishops warn traditionalists on Holocaust denial (Expatica)

Pope reaffirms 'solidarity' with Jews amid row over bishop who denied Holocaust (Haaretz)

Bishops criticise Holocaust denier (Swissinfo)

Iudicium perversum (Jerusalem Post)

The Pope and the Anti-Semitic Bishop - The Real Story (Fox News)

 

 

Response to articles is welcome. Simply follow the prompts to post your comment. No posting of more than 250 words will be published. While critical comment on stories and issues is welcomed, postings that descend to personal attacks on or impugn the integrity of other commentators will be blocked. Please use your own name, or initials, eg John Brown, or JB, or JAB, or Johnny. You are also required to add your location to the end of your email - as in, Sunshine, Victoria. Please provide your email address in the line supplied, followed by your contact phone number. These are requested for identification purposes only and will not be published. If you have any problems, please email news@cathnews.com

Recent Comments

  1. This Williamson is an odd duck with crazy crackpot ideas. But what I found even more troubling is that all these SSPX bishops and priests will need to be conditionally re-ordained anyway, since their line is questionable, dubious at best: Marcel Lefebvre was ordained by Achilles Lienart, who was a secret Luciferian at the time. He later admitted it during Vatican II but Lefebvre (huge ego) passed up a chance for re-ordination himself.

    So the irony here is that Richard Williamson and company cannot be considered valid until they allow the Pope to re-ordain them!

  2. Phew! I/we can breathe again. This article throws a fuller perspective on the whole situation. Again I should have waited for the whole thing to play out a little more. But will the rest of society get these later news articles, this message? I suspect not.

    The press thrive on sensationalism and fear mongering to get their sales, stuff the immorality of the complete absconding of their responsibilities in regards to the effect they have on society not to mention the complete and unbiased reporting of news and history. Some are trying but the short, sharp, from-the-hip nature of daily secular newspapers and the tiresome, ad nauseum repetition of hourly TV reports these days usually leaves a society of half, nay quarter informed readers who then think they have the whole picture and, therefore, continue to feel justified in throwing out the baby and the bath water of Catholicism/Christianity.

    Oh yet we trust that somehow
    good shall be the final goal of ill.

  3. It would be the right thing for Bishop Williamson to apologise for his statements that seek to diminish the number of Jews murdered by the Nazis.
    But there should also be an apology from the Jewish Rabbis who seek to cut ties with the Vatican because of the Pope lifting the excommunications from the SSPX bishops. This is unjust interference from non-Catholics, in this case Jews, in Catholic affairs that are none of their business.
    If the Rabbinical Councils seek to excommunicate or revoke excommunications on their own co-religionists that is none of my concern and none of the Pope's concern.

  4. Our poor dear Pope Benedict. He seems to have to walk on egg-shells, these days. Why do Catholics let him down so consistently! He has my prayers.


  5. Admirably enough and like a true Catholic brother, Bishop Williamson has apologised to The Pope for his comments.

    Normally, that should be an end to the matter but for those who hate The Church and especially traditional Catholicism it will never suffice.

    Furthermore, he is not the only bishop out there who owes the Holy Father an apology for "unwise comments". We have heard those aplenty from Bishops across the Catholic world during Pope Benedict XVI's pontificate. It is about time they wrote letters of apology too.

    http://remnantnewspaper.com/Archives/2009-now_also_bishop_williamson.htm


    http://www.kreuz.net/article.8575.html

  6. I would like to suggest that contributors Google: The Victime of Yalta - Nikolai Tolstoy
    From page dsplayed, call up: Nikoilai Tolstoy and the Victims of Yalta (1 bit long sorry)
    This link will tell of what is described as a heinous war crime against Soviet citizens in the hands of western allies. Most would have been our brothers and sisters in the Orthodox faith. Their story should be widely know.Most know of the Yalta Conference.
    Because of the spotlight on the Holocaust, this is relevant. Prayers for Holocaust victims and other victims of war are needed.

  7. "...there should also be an apology from the Jewish Rabbis who seek to cut ties with the Vatican because of the Pope lifting the excommunications from the SSPX bishops. This is unjust interference from non-Catholics, in this case Jews, in Catholic affairs that are none of their business."

    It's no interference. The Chief Rabbinate is setting limits, saying that if the Church is going to go in a particular direction, the Chief Rabbinate can't go along. The Church is free to do what it wants.

  8. Richard P,whether or not Cardinal Achilles Lienart was a secret Luciferian, later self-confessed, is really beside the point when considering the episcopal orders of Archbishop Marcel-Francois Lefebvre.

    Although the apostolic succession is often shown simply through the principal consecrator, Lefebvre was also episcopally ordained by two other bishops as required.

    That only one co-consecrator is a validly ordained bishop himself is all that is needed for validity. To provide such certainty is one of several reasons why the Church, East and West, requires at least three ordaining bishops.

    Occasionally, usually in times of persecution, the Holy See has granted dispensations for episcopal ordinations to be conferred by two bishops or even one.But that's another matter.

    However, in Lefebvre's case the two co-consecrators were A-J-F Ancel and J-B Fauret. Neither of these was a secret anything as far as I can determine.

    Also, Richard, could you please provide a RELIABLE source as to the alleged Luciferianism of Card. Achilles Lienart and his later public (?) confession of such deviant tendencies.

  9. HMacK....how can Bishop Williamson be a true Christian brother.....did he not also write that women, normally, should not attend University; that women should not wear trousers. Does he not support the dishonest Prtotocols of the Elders of Zion? He might be your "brother" but he's not mine.....not until he repents and apologises to tthe Jewish people.

    The pope owes the Church an apology....for being extremely foolish and for bringing the Body of Christ into disrepute. This decision is scandalous. Let's drop these infantile titles "Holy Father".....there's only one Holy Father: God the Father. We know some popes have believed that they are "God on earth" but let's not fall into that heresy.

Delicious

More from this section

  1. Williamson comments risk new "Regensburg": Fears

    The Vatican's "damage control machine" is reported to have "gone into high gear" over the reaction to the lifting of the excommunication of four SSPX bishops, including the controversial Bishop Richard Williamson.

  2. Pope challenges "digital generation"

    Pope Benedict chose World Communications Day to launch the Vatican's YouTube channel, and praised social networking sites for fostering friendships and understanding, but warning they also can isolate people.

  3. YCW grows after WYD

    World Youth Day 2008 has led to unprecedented growth in the Australian Young Christian Workers movement, according to national secretary Marie Rehab.

  4. Catholic agencies warn against mining methods

    Catholic development network, CIDSE, has slammed current methods of extracting natural resources in Latin America as leading to loss of livelihood, violent conflict, persistent human rights violations and environmental degradation.

  5. Crisis for rich, opportunity for rest: World Social Forum founder

    As the 2009 World Social Forum opened in Belem, Brazil, co-founder and Catholic activist, Chico Whitaker, told a forum on liberation and theology that the global economic crisis was also an opportunity "to build another world".

Church Resources provides a range of services for the Church and not-for-profit sector, including aggregating buying power for a wide range of products and services used by health, welfare, aged care, education and parish organisations. More »

Subscribe

Receive CathNews headlines in your inbox daily.

News Feed

Subscribe to the CathNews RSS feed to get the daily edition automatically delivered to you.

Daily Prayer

Gospel Verse for 30 July 2010
"A prophet is not without honor except in his own country..." [Matthew 13:57]

View Podcast